Shop
EN

Sections

Language

Reading list

This list is saved in this browser on this device.

Your list is empty. Save an article using the bookmark icon to find it here.

CULTURE

The Yankees cap: history of the NY logo, New Era and the 59FIFTY

Casquette des Yankees : histoire du logo NY, de New Era et de la 59FIFTY

The Yankees cap combines the NY logo, adopted in 1909 by the team then called the Highlanders, with New Era’s 59FIFTY, a fitted model designed in 1954. It left the field after 1996, when Spike Lee got a red version for the World Series, and then moved into hip-hop and streetwear. The often-told story of a logo “designed by Louis B. Tiffany” rests on no document found: a 1877 police medal made by Tiffany & Co. carries an interlocking NY, but nothing proves the team drew on it.

At a glance

  • Logo: the interlocking NY was adopted in 1909 by the Highlanders, who became the Yankees in 1913.
  • Origin: the 1877 Tiffany & Co. police medal is the team’s version, with no 1909 document found.
  • New Era: founded in Buffalo in 1920, 59FIFTY designed in 1954.
  • License: exclusive supplier of MLB on-field caps since 1993 (1994 according to other sources).
  • Culture: Spike Lee’s red cap in 1996, reissued on May 9, 2026.
  • Sizes: from 7 (55.8 cm) to 8 (63.5 cm).

The Yankees cap in 10 dates

The Yankees cap in ten dates: 1860 Brooklyn Excelsiors, 1909 interlocking NY adopted by the Highlanders, 1920 New Era founded in Buffalo, 1934 first MLB cap, 1954 59FIFTY, 1990 Nelson Mandela at Yankee Stadium, 1993 New Era becomes MLB supplier, 1996 Spike Lee’s red cap, 2009 Empire State of Mind No. 1 on the Hot 100, 2026 Spike Lee x New Era collection.
Ten dates of the Yankees cap, from the Brooklyn Excelsiors’ cap in 1860 to the New Era x Spike Lee collection of 2026.

Who designed the NY logo? What the sources say

The interlocking NY became the team’s logo in 1909, under the name Highlanders, and has been the cap insignia since (Wikipedia). A version in which the Y overlaps the N had been used in 1905, and the New York Giants also wore an interlocking NY in 1908 or 1909 (Baseball Researcher, Barry Popik).

According to the team, Tiffany & Co. supposedly designed the logo for a medal of valor given in 1877 to John McDowell, a police officer wounded in the line of duty, and Bill Devery, a former police chief and co-owner of the club, supposedly had it adopted (6sqft, “according to the franchise”; Wikipedia). The table tests this account against the sources.

ClaimWhat the sources showStatus
McDowell received a medal in 1877Wounded on January 8, 1877 during a burglary; the back of the medal carries his name and the date January 12, 1877 (Baseball Researcher, which cites period newspapers).Established
Tiffany & Co. made the medalThe lower edge reads “TIFFANY & CO., N.Y.” (Baseball Researcher).Plausible, single source
It was designed by “Louis B. Tiffany”Name from the Yankees’ 2009 media guide, repeated by Untapped Cities. Louis Comfort Tiffany worked with glass in Brooklyn in the 1870s and became design director of Tiffany & Co. only in 1902 (Wikipedia). Baseball Researcher considers it almost certain that he did not design it.Unsupported
It inspired the Yankees logoThe two NYs look alike, but Baseball Researcher finds neither a 1909 article explaining the choice nor decisive proof.Unproven
Devery brought the design to the clubCo-owner from 1903 to 1915 and a former policeman; no proof of his role (Baseball Researcher).Hypothesis
McDowell was the first officer wounded, or the first medal recipientThe New York Daily Tribune of September 30, 1854 reports the death of James Cahill, an officer shot the day before (Baseball Researcher). The first recipient of a valor medal was Bernard Tully, on August 17, 1871 (NYPD History).False

The earliest account the Baseball Researcher author found is a New York Times article of April 11, 1992. The sources agree on the 1909 adoption and on the existence of the medal, not on the link between the two: the logo’s designer remains unknown.

Timeline: from the baseball cap to the 59FIFTY

DateEventSources
1860The Brooklyn Excelsiors wear a cap with a long brim and a rounded crown, close to the modern model.Heddels ; Wikipedia
1909The Highlanders adopt the interlocking NY.Wikipedia ; Baseball Researcher
1920Ehrhardt Koch founds New Era in Buffalo: 60,000 Gatsby-style caps in the first year.New Era
1934New Era’s first professional baseball cap, for the Cleveland Indians.New Era ; Baseball Hall of Fame
1954Harold Koch designs the 59FIFTY: flat visor, high crown.New Era ; Heddels
June 21, 1990Nelson Mandela wears a Yankees jacket and cap at Yankee Stadium.ABC7NY ; Andscape
1993New Era becomes the exclusive supplier of MLB on-field caps (1994 according to other sources).New Era ; Baseball Hall of Fame
1996Spike Lee gets a red Yankees cap for Game 3 of the World Series.New Era ; Complex
November 28, 2009Jay-Z and Alicia Keys’ “Empire State of Mind” is No. 1 on the Hot 100 for five weeks.Stereogum ; Wikipedia
May 9, 2026New Era reissues the 1996 red cap for 59FIFTY Day.Complex ; Fashion Mannuscript

New Era: licenses and sales

New Era supplied MLB teams from 1934 and in 1993 became the exclusive supplier of on-field caps (New Era; 1994 according to the Chicago Tribune and Heddels). It took the NFL sidelines in 2012 and the NBA court in 2016. No sales figure specific to the Yankees cap is published by New Era or MLB in the sources checked, and New Era’s revenue appears on Wikipedia without a date or a clear source: we do not use either. The only dated data point concerns MLB merchandise: according to FanGraphs, the White Sox went from 18th of 26 teams at the end of 1990 to 3rd in August 1991, behind the Yankees and the Athletics.

From Yankee Stadium to the street: Mandela, hip-hop, Spike Lee, Jay-Z

On June 21, 1990, Nelson Mandela spoke at Yankee Stadium. Mayor David Dinkins put a Yankees jacket and cap on him, and he told the crowd he was a Yankee (ABC7NY; Andscape). A caption under an AP photo quoted by Andscape gives June 22; we keep the 21st, the date on the Monument Park plaque.

In the 1980s and 1990s, rappers took up fitted baseball caps (Heddels, Chicago Tribune). The Yankees were not alone: FanGraphs notes that N.W.A. wore White Sox caps in 1991. Wikipedia names Jay-Z, Eazy-E, Dr. Dre, the Beastie Boys and Aaliyah among the artists who popularized the 59FIFTY.

In 1996, Spike Lee asked New Era for a red Yankees cap, to match his jacket, for Game 3 of the World Series. At the time, MLB caps came only in teams’ official colors, and the Yankees’ were navy. With the approval of owner George Steinbrenner and MLB, New Era made one (New Era, Complex, Baseball Hall of Fame). According to the brand’s historian quoted by the Chicago Tribune, it changed New Era’s business overnight. The sources checked do not document other custom orders by Spike Lee in the late 1990s.

“Empire State of Mind”, by Jay-Z with Alicia Keys, reached No. 1 on the Hot 100 dated November 28, 2009 and stayed there for five weeks (Stereogum, Wikipedia). In it Jay-Z claims to have made the Yankees cap more famous than the team’s players. Highsnobiety points out that he is not solely responsible for its popularity.

Recent collaborations around the cap

DateCollaborationWhat the sources saySources
July 17, 2014Spike Lee x New Era, Heritage SeriesFour caps, including the red one, at selected dealers.XXL
May 3 to 9, 2026New Era x Spike Lee, 30th anniversarySeven Yankees caps: six navy, one a day from May 3 to 8, then the red one on May 9 (59FIFTY Day), with a side patch and a signature under the visor. No restock announced.Fashion Mannuscript ; Collater.al ; Complex
July 2026Paper Planes x New Era, JAŸ-Z30Yankees cap launched for Jay-Z’s concerts at Yankee Stadium (July 10 and 11, 2026 announced, three nights according to Hypebeast). Descriptions of the model differ, so we do not use them.Stereogum ; Hypebeast ; Sole Retriever

Choosing the size and color of a fitted cap

New Era advises measuring your head with a flexible tape, about 1.3 cm (half an inch) above your eyebrows and ears, snug but not tight. Between two sizes, it recommends rounding up (size chart). The centimeter figure on the label does not always match head circumference.

SizeInchesCentimeters
72255.8
7⅛22⅜56.8
7¼22¾57.7
7⅜23⅛58.7
7½23½59.6
7⅝23⅞60.6
7¾24¼61.5
7⅞24⅝62.5
82563.5

Navy is the original color of Yankees caps; other colorways have existed since the 1996 red cap. The 59FIFTY has a flat visor and a high, structured crown (New Era). Material changes the care: New Era describes polyester as the most forgiving and wool blend as the most delicate (care guide). If you hesitate, choose the color you will wear with the most outfits.

Present your own clothing before production

Are you preparing a brand or merchandise? These files help you present pieces before production. None of them is a cap mockup, and none has any link with the Yankees, New Era or the other brands mentioned in this article.

All HYTRAPE mockups.

Frequently asked questions

Who designed the Yankees’ NY logo?

The sources checked do not say. The team adopted the interlocking NY in 1909. The most widespread explanation, an 1877 police medal made by Tiffany & Co., is backed by no 1909 document, and the name “Louis B. Tiffany” repeated by some sites matches no identified designer at the firm.

When did the Yankees cap become a fashion item?

In 1996, when Spike Lee got a red version from New Era for the World Series, which New Era presents as its entry into streetwear. Hip-hop already wore fitted baseball caps in the 1980s and 1990s, and Jay-Z’s “Empire State of Mind” (2009) then put the Yankees cap in the spotlight.

What do sizes 7⅛ or 7¼ mean on a cap?

They are hat sizes in inches. At New Era, a 7⅛ corresponds to a head circumference of 22⅜ inches (56.8 cm) and a 7¼ to 22¾ inches (57.7 cm); circumference divided by π gives roughly the size.

How do I choose the size of a fitted cap?

Measure your head with a flexible tape about 1.3 cm above your eyebrows and ears, snug but not tight, then read the size in New Era’s chart. Between two sizes, New Era recommends the larger one.

How can I tell if a New Era cap is authentic?

New Era advises buying from its official sites or stores: auction sites do not guarantee authenticity, and sites imitating its own sell counterfeits. The gold visor sticker, used on all fitted caps since 2015, is a common marker but it peels off, so do not rely on it alone. A counterfeit can be reported on New Era’s Brand Protection page.

How do I clean a 59FIFTY cap?

New Era asks for spot cleaning: a damp cloth with a little mild detergent, cool water (lukewarm for cotton), no soaking, no washing machine and no dryer, then air drying. For a sweat stain, it suggests a baking soda paste left for 15 minutes before dabbing.

What does 59FIFTY mean?

New Era does not explain the name on the pages checked. Wikipedia reports several explanations, including an original catalog number (5950), a model number or a roll of fabric, without a decisive source.

Read next

Sources

Updated October 23, 2026. Sources checked on this date. The origin of the NY logo remains disputed: the 1877 Tiffany & Co. medal version is not documented by any 1909 source. The dates of New Era’s MLB exclusivity (1993 or 1994) and of Mandela’s visit (June 21 or 22, 1990) vary by source.

HYTRAPE shop · Mockups

Put your reading into practice.

A Mockups selection from HYTRAPE’s independent creators.

View the collection

20,000+ downloads 4.7/5 45 verified reviews

In this article